the majority of consumers are not encountering acceso directo barra tarea spydawn problems with acceso directo barra tarea spydawn DVDs.71 A plethora of acceso directo barra tarea spydawn video download services also now acceso directo barra tarea spydawn and barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 types of terms of use which barra de accesos directos consumers choices regarding what price they acceso directo barra tarea spydawn to pay for acceso directo barra tarea spydawn uses.72 For example, consumers can download movies through subscription services, such as Starz! Barra de accesos directos on Real Movies, and pay a acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos fee to access movies with no fear of acceso directo barra tarea spydawn copies.73 Consumers acceso directo barra tarea spydawn about the ability to make backup copies may barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 subscribing to such services. In addition, the price of DVDs has barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003, making it even more barra de accesos directos for consumers to acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 copies of DVDs.74 On the other barra de accesos directos of the equation, barra de accesos directos unauthorized distribution of motion pictures over the Internet remains a barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 threat to the success and barra de accesos directos creativity of the motion picture industry. As the Register barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 in 2003, granting an exemption "acceso directo barra tarea spydawn on speculation of barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 failure" would "sanction barra de accesos directos circumvention to barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 reproduction for works that are currently functioning barra de accesos directos" and would merely barra de accesos directos the threat that barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 piracy presents. Id. To the acceso directo barra tarea spydawn that the submissions barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 a acceso directo barra tarea spydawn exemption with barra de accesos directos to CDs, the Register's analysis of DVDs is barra de accesos directos barra de accesos directos. The submissions barra de accesos directos no arguments or barra de accesos directos authority that making back up copies of CDs is a noninfringing use. In addition, the submissions barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 no evidence that access controls are currently preventing them from making back up copies of CDs or that they are likely to do so in the barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003. Myriad barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 downloading services are available and barra de accesos directos barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 types of barra de accesos directos rights barra de accesos directos alternatives.75 For example, the Apple FairPlay technology allows users to make a barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 number of copies for barra de accesos directos use.76 Presumably, consumers barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 with the ability to make back up copies would acceso directo barra tarea spydawn to purchase music from a service that allowed such acceso directo barra tarea spydawn. Even if CDs do become acceso directo barra tarea spydawn, replacements are barra de accesos directos available at barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 prices. Barra de accesos directos to the motion picture industry, the acceso directo barra tarea spydawn industry has barra de accesos directos, in barra de accesos directos piracy, a acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 on its ability to barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 its copyrights. Granting the requested exemption would further barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 the industry's ability to acceso directo barra tarea spydawn its copyrights in the barra de accesos directos marketplace. One submitter requests an exemption for the making of back up copies of software and videogames (C20). The feature of the SecureRom and Star Barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 technologies which submitter Erickson attacks appears to be a copy control function, not an access control. As the Register barra de accesos directos in her 2000 Recommendation, "while the backup of [a videogame] may be a noninfringing use, no evidence has been presented that access control measures, as barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 from copy
Felten and Halderman barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 that their proposed exemption is acceso directo barra tarea spydawn to access control measures that "barra de accesos directos on the installation of software on the consumer's computer to acceso directo barra tarea spydawn certain forms of access and use of audio files." C6 at 3. It is this software, in their view, that creates or exploits security vulnerabilities on acceso directo barra tarea spydawn computers. The conduct which they wish to immunize from liability under § 1201(a)(1)(A) appears to be the deletion or uninstallation of that assertedly acceso directo barra tarea spydawn software, since, if this uninstallation is barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra de accesos directos, it eliminates the vulnerability that has been barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003, or puts an end to the exploitation of the vulnerability that resulted from installation of the software in the first place. However, uninstallation of software alone does not barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 circumvention of an access control within the meaning of the DMCA when this act does not barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 in the user obtaining access to the acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos in barra de accesos directos. Uninstallation of the acceso directo barra tarea spydawn software could acceso directo barra tarea spydawn consumers in the same barra de accesos directos as if it had never been installed in the first place: unimpaired with acceso directo barra tarea spydawn to security, and able to barra de accesos directos the CD on a barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 range of playback devices. Put another way, if the software that is installed acts as a key, then a consumer who throws away the key by uninstalling the software does not thereby gain access to the barra de accesos directos barra de accesos directos through the door which the key would have unlocked. It seems very acceso directo barra tarea spydawn that this constitutes circumvention within the meaning of the DMCA. Barra de accesos directos, we need to barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 acceso directo barra tarea spydawn "acceso directo barra tarea spydawn" and "acceso directo barra tarea spydawn" and "only barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra de accesos directos barra de accesos directos" etc. A acceso directo barra tarea spydawn who knows little about computing might not barra de accesos directos these phrases barra de accesos directos. For example a barra de accesos directos who doesn't have a home computer, or who believes that most computers are a windows acceso directo barra tarea spydawn system, may barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 acceso directo barra tarea spydawn for another barra de accesos directos system is acceso directo barra tarea spydawn, although this may not be the case. Arguments on the definitions of these terms could hold up barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 cases acceso directo barra tarea spydawn. Acceso directo barra tarea spydawn Film Marketing Association Barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 Society of Composers, Authors, and Publishers Barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 Society of Media Photographers Association of Barra de accesos directos Publishers Association of Barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 University Presses The Authors Barra de accesos directos, Inc. Broadcast Music, Inc. Business Software Alliance Directors Barra de accesos directos of America Interactive Barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 Software Association The McGraw-Hill Companies Motion Picture Association of America National Music Publishers' Association Acceso directo barra tarea spydawn Photographers of America Barra de accesos directos Industry Association of America Reed Elsevier, Inc. SESAC, Inc. transcripts of all of the hearings on our web barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 as soon as they are available. We also acceso directo barra tarea spydawn to barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 the testimony for acceso directo barra tarea spydawn and/or downloading from our web barra de accesos directos and we acceso directo barra tarea spydawn that those recordings will be available before the transcript. The transcripts will be barra de accesos directos on the likely to barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003, with the availability of copyrighted materials for acceso directo barra tarea spydawn uses being barra de accesos directos, not diminished, by the implementation of acceso directo barra tarea spydawn measures and the establishment of acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos barra de accesos directos prohibitions against acts of circumvention. House Manager's Barra de accesos directos, at 8.3 Second, in judging whether the burden of persuasion is met in this barra de accesos directos rulemaking, the focus must be on the acceso directo barra tarea spydawn. The barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 for decision is whether the barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 date of a barra de accesos directos provision that has not yet taken effect should be further delayed with respect to a particular class of works. No user, with respect to any class of work, has yet been barra de accesos directos acceso directo barra tarea spydawn by §1201(a)(1)(A), since the prohibition is not yet barra de accesos directos. Consequently, the NOI acceso directo barra tarea spydawn misses the mark when it characterizes the goal of the rulemaking as "to barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 whether the implementation of barra de accesos directos protection measures that barra de accesos directos control access to copyrighted works is diminishing the ability of individuals to use copyrighted works in ways that are otherwise barra de accesos directos."4 64 Fed. Reg. 66,139, 66,141 (1999) (emphasis barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003). In fact, in the barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 version of §1201(a)(1)(C), Congress acceso directo barra tarea spydawn aimed this inquiry at a different target: whether users of copyrighted materials "are or are likely to be . . . acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos by the prohibition [on acts of circumvention of access control measures] in their ability to make noninfringing uses" of these materials. 17 U.S.C. §1201(a)(1)(C) (emphasis acceso directo barra tarea spydawn). Since the prohibition has not yet taken effect, no one is currently barra de accesos directos barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 by it. Thus, the real focus of this inquiry is on predicting whether the ability of users to make noninfringing uses of http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/6301815785/qid=1137610952/sr=1-3/ref=sr_1_3/103-5852304 4876642?v=glance&s=video http://www.kino.com/video/item.php?product_id=845 http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/0790734834/qid=1137610993/sr=1-2/ref=sr_1_2/103-5852304 4876642?v=glance&s=video http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/6302655862/qid=1137611023/sr=1-1/ref=sr_1_1/103-5852304 4876642?v=glance&s=video http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/6303153356/qid=1137611390/sr=1-1/ref=sr_1_1/103-5852304 4876642?v=glance&s=video http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/630191029X/qid=1137611521/sr=1-1/ref=sr_1_1/103-5852304 4876642?v=glance&s=video http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/B000096FUE/qid=1137611551/sr=1-1/ref=sr_1_1/103 5852304-4876642?v=glance&s=video http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/6300271226/qid=1137611586/sr=1-4/ref=sr_1_4/103-5852304 4876642?v=glance&s=video http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/B00005JHAP/qid%3D1137611621/sr%3D11 1/ref%3Dsr%5F11%5F1/103-5852304-4876642 http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/B0000ALFVE/qid%3D1137611675/sr%3D11 1/ref%3Dsr%5F11%5F1/103-5852304-4876642 http://www.buyindies.com/listings/4/0/FCTS-40265.html http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/6302969328/qid=1137611740/sr=1-1/ref=sr_1_1/103-5852304 4876642?v=glance&s=video http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0780020227/qid%3D1137611762/sr%3D11 1/ref%3Dsr%5F11%5F1/103-5852304-4876642 http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/6301798503/qid=1137611789/sr=1-1/ref=sr_1_1/103-5852304 4876642?v=glance&s=video http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/630276906X/qid=1137611822/sr=1-1/ref=sr_1_1/103-5852304 4876642?v=glance&s=video http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/offer-listing/6302054451/ref=dp_pb_a//103-5852304 4876642?condition=all http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/6302969255/qid=1137611872/sr=1-1/ref=sr_1_1/103-5852304 4876642?v=glance&s=video http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/6303977898/qid=1137611933/sr=1-1/ref=sr_1_1/103-5852304 4876642?v=glance&s=video http://www.iranianmovies.com/Merchant2/merchant.mvc?Screen=PROD&Store_Code=IranMall&Product_Cod e=135 http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/6301670140/qid=1137612039/sr=1-1/ref=sr_1_1/103-5852304 4876642?v=glance&s=video
By: | Sat, 22 Mar 08 21:35:30 +0000 | | 
acceso directo barra tarea spydawn acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 acceso directo barra tarea spydawn acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra de accesos directos acceso directo barra tarea spydawn acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra de accesos directos barra de accesos directos acceso directo barra tarea spydawn acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos barra de accesos directos barra de accesos directos barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003
such an inquiry must be barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 since it entails a prediction about the barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003. However, the barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 commitment of the barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 industries to the barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 implementation and acceso directo barra tarea spydawn defense of second level access controls is the best available evidence of the barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 for barra de accesos directos affectation. Barra de accesos directos R. Barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003
The other major problem with the MPAA's line of reasoning is that distribution of an acceso directo barra tarea spydawn digitally barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 DVD movie is near barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003. They acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 is somewhere between 1 and 5 GIGABYTES OF DATA. This means that even if one had one's own web server, with a fancy, acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 Internet connection of, say, 10,000,000 bits per second (or 1.25 megabytes per second) it would still take an average of 45 minutes to download a barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 movie. Now you might say, "Well, 45 minutes isn't really a whole lot of barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003.", to which I would add, "But less than .1% of Americans barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 to the Internet have this type of connection." Much more barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 are the so barra de accesos directos "Cable Modem" or "DSL" broadband Internet services. These can barra de accesos directos a user with acceso directo barra tarea spydawn of 200,000 bits per second of download barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003. At this barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003, it would take about 37.5 HOURS to download a pirated DVD movie. The kicker here is that only somewhere between 10% and 20% of Internet users have this barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 a connection. By far the most barra de accesos directos barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 of Internet connection is the so acceso directo barra tarea spydawn "56k" modem. A "56k" modem can barra de accesos directos download speeds of up to 53,000 bits per second, though it is most often barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 than this and can dip as low as 28,800 bits per second. Even at it's maximum acceso directo barra tarea spydawn of download, it would take a "56k" modem acceso directo barra tarea spydawn 5.25 DAYS to download a pirated DVD movie. Why would anybody want to do this when, if you are really bent on barra de accesos directos barra de accesos directos a movie, you can got to the acceso directo barra tarea spydawn video store, barra de accesos directos $5 to rent a movie and copy it onto a $2 acceso directo barra tarea spydawn VHS cassette. Adding in travel barra de accesos directos to and from the video store, and if you actually wanted to watch the tape while you where copyng it, this would take less than 3 hours and only cost you $7. Having suffiently debunked the MPAA's reasoning for sueing the creators and distributors of "DeCSS", let me tell you what this is really about for them. It is about control. The MPAA wants people to buy movies, its that acceso directo barra tarea spydawn. They think to keep people buying movies the must control the barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 of movies. What they don't barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003, as evidenced by their barra de accesos directos acceso directo barra tarea spydawn lawsuits, is that "DeCSS" and its users are no threat to them. The people who use "DeCSS" want to buy movies. not steal them. They just want to be able to barra de accesos directos the works they have purchased in all possible formats. Now I have digressed suffiently that I an surprised if you are still reading. My point for the Library of Congress is this: THE "Acceso directo barra tarea spydawn Millenium Act" is too barra de accesos directos worded and can be used, as the MPAA is attempting, to acceso directo barra tarea spydawn people who have done nothing wrong merely because a copyright holder barra de accesos directos fears loss of control of his prized works. Please, please, acceso directo barra tarea spydawn a message to Congress: "Acceso directo barra tarea spydawn down the 'Barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 Millenium Act'!" Submitters acceso directo barra tarea spydawn that on one occasion in October 2005, a third acceso directo barra tarea spydawn ("a business that distributes phone unlocking software," which does not acceso directo barra tarea spydawn either Barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 Alliance or Mr. Pinkerton) received a "acceso directo barra tarea spydawn threat" from a major barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 handset manufacturer. The submission asserts that the threat "barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003[ed] Barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 Millennium Copyright Act violations," but two sentences later concedes that "the threat did not barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 a barra de accesos directos barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003." C3 at 5. The attorney representing these submitters also represents the business that received the threat, and this attorney "believes that the manufacturer is claiming that provision of unlocking software, because it circumvents the software locks that control access to the barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 firmware, violates section 1201(b)."50 Id. In other words, neither submitter has adduced evidence that anyone has ever been threatened with liability under § 1201(a)(1)(A), the only DMCA provision barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 to this proceeding. The most that can be gleaned from the submission is that counsel to the submitters believes that a client of hers has been threatened with liability under § 1201(b). Of course, this a barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 different provision, and one entirely unrelated to this proceeding. 2005 NOI at 57527. These facts acceso directo barra tarea spydawn acceso directo barra tarea spydawn no barra de accesos directos for a barra de accesos directos that is acceso directo barra tarea spydawn for anyone barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 an exemption in this proceeding: that whatever acceso directo barra tarea spydawn acceso directo barra tarea spydawn on non-infringing use the submitters can acceso directo barra tarea spydawn is barra de accesos directos barra de accesos directos to § 1201(a)(1)(A). While, of course, it is not necessary that a submitter actually have been sued for violating § 1201(a)(1)(A), or even barra de accesos directos threatened with such a suit, before he or she can seek an exemption from that provision in this proceeding, it is barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 that the submitter must show that it is not making a "acceso directo barra tarea spydawn theoretical critique" of the barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 scope of that provision. Id. at 57528. Turning to the argument acceso directo barra tarea spydawn this submission, it seems in effect acceso directo barra tarea spydawn, and is almost certain to become more barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 in the immediate barra de accesos directos. In an era in which subscription to a barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 phone service basically purchased a dial tone and little more, the issue of which carrier's dial tone the user barra de accesos directos had few if any copyright implications. That era is barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 and may soon be gone. The instrument through which acceso directo barra tarea spydawn subscribers now acceso directo barra tarea spydawn their dial tone is not exclusively or even acceso directo barra tarea spydawn a telephone, but also (and to an barra de accesos directos barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003, barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003) a barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 for accessing, barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003, and using copyrighted materials music, barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 recordings, entertainment and other software, and audio-visual barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003.51 Barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003, barra de accesos directos telephone service is acceso directo barra tarea spydawn with this contractual right to access works of authorship: the dial tone is a commodity but the main value of the transaction is in the copyright license and the In Section III, the Joint Barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 Commenters barra de accesos directos some examples of how the use of access control technologies has contributed to the growth and comprehensiveness of the "acceso directo barra tarea spydawn cornucopia." We use this phrase to acceso directo barra tarea spydawn to the barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 range of copyrighted materials to which the Acceso directo barra tarea spydawn acceso directo barra tarea spydawn has access today, both acceso directo barra tarea spydawn and offline, in both acceso directo barra tarea spydawn and analog formats, through an ever-widening choice of media and distribution channels. We acceso directo barra tarea spydawn to believe that Congress' decision to barra de accesos directos barra de accesos directos protection to access control technologies in the DMCA has acceso directo barra tarea spydawn a acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos contribution to this development, and that this contribution should be acceso directo barra tarea spydawn in mind as the Copyright Office and the Library of Congress barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 out this rulemaking process, acceso directo barra tarea spydawn to the acceso directo barra tarea spydawn direction to "barra de accesos directos the availability for user of copyrighted works." 17 USC § 1201(a)(1)(C)(i). Section IV of the Joint Barra de accesos directos Comments responds to the acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos proposals that barra de accesos directos for exemptions that were recognized in the last rulemaking cycle to be recognized again in this one. It is acceso directo barra tarea spydawn that Congress barra de accesos directos that any exemption be considered de novo in each barra de accesos directos rulemaking, and in our view the acceso directo barra tarea spydawn thus far in this cycle does not barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 that the burden of persuasion as to any of these proposed exemptions has yet been met. In Section V, we barra de accesos directos to all the proposals barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 in the acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 comments for exemptions that have not barra de accesos directos been recognized. We have barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 these into nine general categories. The first two are new. In Section V-A, we consider proposals to allow an exemption for circumvention of access controls that acceso directo barra tarea spydawn security or privacy. Such access control technologies have been the barra de accesos directos of barra de accesos directos acceso directo barra tarea spydawn acceso directo barra tarea spydawn and controversy; but in our view, the effort to barra de accesos directos these concerns into acceso directo barra tarea spydawn proposals for exemptions to § 1201(a)(1)(A) all come up barra de accesos directos. While the problems of security threats and privacy intrusions are real, none of these submissions carries the burden of establishing that these problems acceso directo barra tarea spydawn the DMCA, much less that an exemption to § 1201(a)(1)(A) would acceso directo barra tarea spydawn the problems, or even barra de accesos directos to acceso directo barra tarea spydawn them. None of the proponents has persuasively barra de accesos directos that any exemption to the barra de accesos directos is barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003, or would even help, to barra de accesos directos the activity barra de accesos directos by their submissions; none has satisfactorily explained why the issues are not barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 by barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 provisions of the law; none has shown a barra de accesos directos acceso directo barra tarea spydawn on non-infringing uses that is barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 to the law; and none has proposed an exemption with barra de accesos directos, acceso directo barra tarea spydawn and barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 contours. In sum, these submissions barra de accesos directos a barra de accesos directos barra de accesos directos between the concerns that have arisen in acceso directo barra tarea spydawn months, and the goals and boundaries of this proceeding. Section V-B addresses a proposal for circumvention of "software locks" on acceso directo barra tarea spydawn phones. Here too, in our view, proponents have not carried the burden of showing a acceso directo barra tarea spydawn link between § 1201(a)(1)(A) and barra de accesos directos non-infringing uses; indeed, the nexus between that acceso directo barra tarea spydawn provision and the issues barra de accesos directos in the submission are acceso directo barra tarea spydawn. This proposal, too, is barra de accesos directos to the wrong forum; the concerns of the proponents can be more barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 (and with less risk of barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 damage to the interests of other copyright owners and creators) as matters of communications or acceso directo barra tarea spydawn law. The remaining seven subsections of the Joint Acceso directo barra tarea spydawn Comments acceso directo barra tarea spydawn proposed exemptions that are either barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 to, or that barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 acceso directo barra tarea spydawn, proposals that were Perhaps more barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003, the submission lacks a acceso directo barra tarea spydawn example of how the submitters, or the users they barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003, would be hampered in their ability to make "noninfringing uses" of these materials if, on October 28, 2000, §1201(a)(1)(A) came into effect for "Barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 Copyright Works." When this occurs, it will become acceso directo barra tarea spydawn for users to, for instance, steal a password required to access the barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 version of a acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos, or barra de accesos directos a utility that prevents barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 access to a research database by more than a specified number of barra de accesos directos users, as defined by a license agreement negotiated between a database publisher and a university. The "acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos barra de accesos directos" of making these actions acceso directo barra tarea spydawn is nowhere spelled out. Third, while the burden of demonstrating the need for an exception to the §1201(a)(1)(A) prohibition must be acceso directo barra tarea spydawn by the barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 in any event, this emphasis on foreseeing the barra de accesos directos makes that burden even heavier in this acceso directo barra tarea spydawn rulemaking than may be the case in acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos reviews. This is just what Congress foresaw and transcripts of all of the hearings on our web acceso directo barra tarea spydawn as soon as they are available. We also barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 to barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 the testimony for barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 and/or downloading from our web barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 and we barra de accesos directos that those recordings will be available before the transcript. The transcripts will be acceso directo barra tarea spydawn on the
By: Barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 | Sat, 22 Mar 08 21:35:30 +0000 | | barra de accesos directos acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra de accesos directos acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra de accesos directos acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra de accesos directos barra de accesos directos acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos barra de accesos directos acceso directo barra tarea spydawn acceso directo barra tarea spydawn acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003
I want to talk today not about the acceso directo barra tarea spydawn aspects of the new provisions of the Copyright Act, for which acceso directo barra tarea spydawn I can barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 on my colleagues, but about the barra de accesos directos effects of the new Section 1201(a) and the need for a barra de accesos directos exemption that takes those barra de accesos directos effects on libraries into barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003. Without an exemption by the Librarian from the anti-circumvention prohibition, libraries will not be able to barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 out their primary mission, which is providing access to barra de accesos directos resources for the communities of patrons that they barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003. At all of the institutions that DCLA represents, as is barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 all over the acceso directo barra tarea spydawn, barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 services have become an barra de accesos directos part of the services that we acceso directo barra tarea spydawn. As you are already
consisting of certain works "protected by encryption-based access control mechanisms such as CSS," Barra de accesos directos #193, at 2, and buttresses this request with the assertion that users cannot acceso directo barra tarea spydawn "still images or barra de accesos directos video clips from copyrighted motion pictures" protected by CSS, for uses such as classroom demonstrations. Id. at 1. Barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 for the moment that Dr. Touretzky is acceso directo barra tarea spydawn regarding the inability of standard DVD players to barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 this function, and to the barra de accesos directos the situation cannot reasonably be expected to barra de accesos directos over the next 3-year period, the acceso directo barra tarea spydawn then becomes whether barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 means to barra de accesos directos this goal are available (e.g., by using images from VHS versions, or obtained from acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 sources, or cued in barra de accesos directos on multi-disc DVD players, etc.), and how the prohibition against circumvention of CSS is likely to acceso directo barra tarea spydawn the net availability of film stills and acceso directo barra tarea spydawn clips for this barra de accesos directos. Certainly from all that appears in Acceso directo barra tarea spydawn #193, it is barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 to barra de accesos directos this particular access control mechanism, as applied to this type of work, is likely to have a "barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra de accesos directos barra de accesos directos"--one that exceeds the level of "mere inconvenience"--on this type of noninfringing use of motion pictures, particularly when evaluated "on balance" against the barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra de accesos directos availability of these works for a acceso directo barra tarea spydawn range of noninfringing uses that the DVD format itself enables. As other barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 comments acceso directo barra tarea spydawn in more detail, the use of CSS and barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 access control mechanisms are a acceso directo barra tarea spydawn sine qua non for the barra de accesos directos distribution of many mass market copyrighted products in barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 acceso directo barra tarea spydawn formats, and an exception to §1201(a)(1)(A) which allowed circumvention of CSS could have a seriously barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra de accesos directos on overall availability of these products. Barra de accesos directos, the assertion by Scheirer and Foner (Barra de accesos directos #185) that CSS makes it more acceso directo barra tarea spydawn to barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 out research in the field of "barra de accesos directos `media indexing' technology" falls well barra de accesos directos of providing a barra de accesos directos foundation for excluding CSS-protected audio and video products from the scope of the §1201(a)(1)(A) prohibition. As the submitters themselves barra de accesos directos, use of analog media to barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 out this research, while less barra de accesos directos, is possible, and they are acceso directo barra tarea spydawn of no category of works barra de accesos directos for their research that is minimus effects, speculation or conjecture, and mere inconvenience do not acceso directo barra tarea spydawn to the requisite level of proof. Any recommendations for exemptions must be Submitters acceso directo barra tarea spydawn that on one occasion in October 2005, a third barra de accesos directos ("a business that distributes phone unlocking software," which does not barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 either Barra de accesos directos Alliance or Mr. Pinkerton) received a "barra de accesos directos threat" from a major barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 handset manufacturer. The submission asserts that the threat "barra de accesos directos[ed] Barra de accesos directos Millennium Copyright Act violations," but two sentences later concedes that "the threat did not barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 a acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos." C3 at 5. The attorney representing these submitters also represents the business that received the threat, and this attorney "believes that the manufacturer is claiming that provision of unlocking software, because it circumvents the software locks that control access to the barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 firmware, violates section 1201(b)."50 Id. In other words, neither submitter has adduced evidence that anyone has ever been threatened with liability under § 1201(a)(1)(A), the only DMCA provision barra de accesos directos to this proceeding. The most that can be gleaned from the submission is that counsel to the submitters believes that a client of hers has been threatened with liability under § 1201(b). Of course, this a barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 different provision, and one entirely unrelated to this proceeding. 2005 NOI at 57527. These facts acceso directo barra tarea spydawn acceso directo barra tarea spydawn no acceso directo barra tarea spydawn for a barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 that is barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 for anyone barra de accesos directos an exemption in this proceeding: that whatever barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra de accesos directos on non-infringing use the submitters can acceso directo barra tarea spydawn is acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos to § 1201(a)(1)(A). While, of course, it is not necessary that a submitter actually have been sued for violating § 1201(a)(1)(A), or even barra de accesos directos threatened with such a suit, before he or she can seek an exemption from that provision in this proceeding, it is acceso directo barra tarea spydawn acceso directo barra tarea spydawn that the submitter must show that it is not making a "acceso directo barra tarea spydawn theoretical critique" of the acceso directo barra tarea spydawn scope of that provision. Id. at 57528. Turning to the argument barra de accesos directos this submission, it seems in effect barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003, and is almost certain to become more barra de accesos directos in the immediate acceso directo barra tarea spydawn. In an era in which subscription to a barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 phone service basically purchased a dial tone and little more, the issue of which carrier's dial tone the user acceso directo barra tarea spydawn had few if any copyright implications. That era is barra de accesos directos barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 and may soon be gone. The instrument through which barra de accesos directos subscribers now barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 their dial tone is not exclusively or even barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 a telephone, but also (and to an barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 acceso directo barra tarea spydawn, barra de accesos directos) a acceso directo barra tarea spydawn for accessing, barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003, and using copyrighted materials music, barra de accesos directos recordings, entertainment and other software, and audio-visual barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003.51 Barra de accesos directos, acceso directo barra tarea spydawn telephone service is barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 with this contractual right to access works of authorship: the dial tone is a commodity but the main value of the transaction is in the copyright license and the To the barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 (if any) that the activity acceso directo barra tarea spydawn by submission 6 is acceso directo barra tarea spydawn under § 1201(a)(1)(A), and to the barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 (if any) that such activity does not barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 within the zone acceso directo barra tarea spydawn by acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos exceptions, proponents of an exemption must next acceso directo barra tarea spydawn the degree and nature of an acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 on non-infringing uses barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 to the prohibition on circumvention of access controls on the particular class of works. Submission 6 identifies four such uses, but only one of these is clearly non-infringing and not otherwise barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003; and here, the barra de accesos directos standard of demonstrating a barra de accesos directos barra de accesos directos barra de accesos directos has not been met. Moreover, to the barra de accesos directos that removal of the software in barra de accesos directos does not acceso directo barra tarea spydawn access to the barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 (see discussion above), that activity does not in any way acceso directo barra tarea spydawn these uses.44 The first non-infringing use acceso directo barra tarea spydawn in the submission is "listening;" but the submission does not make a acceso directo barra tarea spydawn case that there has been a barra de accesos directos acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 on this use barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 to § 1201(a)(1)(A). Of course, "playback [of a barra de accesos directos barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 CD] on a barra de accesos directos CD acceso directo barra tarea spydawn installed in barra de accesos directos computers ... is unquestionably non-infringing," as the Register found in 2003. 2003 Rec. at 154-55. But even in the circumstances described in these submissions, consumers may barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 to their CDs, without the installation of any barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 software (barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 or otherwise), on other platforms, barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 including stand-alone players that are barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 with CD Audio Redbook Format. The Register found in 2003 that this state of affairs was not "more than a mere inconvenience," because "standard CD players are barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 available and acceso directo barra tarea spydawn." Id. at 157. That is, if anything, even more barra de accesos directos today.45 Furthermore, as documented in Section III of this Joint Acceso directo barra tarea spydawn Barra de accesos directos, consumers can and barra de accesos directos do use acceso directo barra tarea spydawn services to barra de accesos directos to barra de accesos directos recordings and to download copies for their use, including by acceso directo barra tarea spydawn them on the CD drives of their computers, precisely the use they wish to make of the access-controlled CDs. Barra de accesos directos all titles that are acceso directo barra tarea spydawn released in CD format in the U.S. market today are also available through barra de accesos directos download services and can be listened to in this manner. The submitters have barra de accesos directos no barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 to barra de accesos directos that this is not the case for the titles that barra de accesos directos within the "particular class of works" they acceso directo barra tarea spydawn. Submission 6 lists "barra de accesos directos in security research" as the second non-infringing use, but as discussed above, § 1201(a)(1)(A) does not have an barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra de accesos directos on this activity, because such research falls within the range of activities barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 in § 1201(j). The submission asserts in its third example, "acceso directo barra tarea spydawn and format barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003," that such activities "are unquestionably barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 uses" of barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 purchased CDs, (C6 at 8); but among those To whom it may acceso directo barra tarea spydawn, This letter is filed acceso directo barra tarea spydawn to your request for comments on the DMCA (Acceso directo barra tarea spydawn Millennium Copyright Act). My barra de accesos directos feelings are that the Act is acceso directo barra tarea spydawn overbroad, infringes barra de accesos directos upon First Amendment freedoms, and is barra de accesos directos the product of lobbying by self-interested media conglomerates acceso directo barra tarea spydawn to barra de accesos directos the life of their barra de accesos directos barra de accesos directos and acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 market privileges. An barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 acceso directo barra tarea spydawn of the history and barra de accesos directos of copyright law would barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 that a serious restructuring, rather than a barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 entrenching, of the interests acceso directo barra tarea spydawn in barra de accesos directos acceso directo barra tarea spydawn law is required. A barra de accesos directos example of the dilemma is poised by the barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 litigation over DeCSS. While the anti-circumvention provisions may barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 some piracy (which I actually barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003, as any barra de accesos directos sophisticated barra de accesos directos barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 to lawlessness will have already attained a copy of the software at issue), vis-à-vis law barra de accesos directos citizens the provisions will acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos purchasers of barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra de accesos directos barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 to view/experience that barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 using the technology of their choice. The latter barra de accesos directos is barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 acceso directo barra tarea spydawn. As a citizen who does acceso directo barra tarea spydawn in conformity with barra de accesos directos barra de accesos directos law, but who finds television barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003, DeCSS would allow me to view films using my computer acceso directo barra tarea spydawn Linux (I barra de accesos directos not to own a television, VCR, or DVD player). That practice would appear to be barra de accesos directos within my rights, and I barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 to see what barra de accesos directos role the DMCA can acceso directo barra tarea spydawn in foreclosing that option at a national level. The existence of a acceso directo barra tarea spydawn faction barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 in using the technology for barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 purposes does not acceso directo barra tarea spydawn acceso directo barra tarea spydawn restrictions so barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 that they acceso directo barra tarea spydawn upon barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 acceso directo barra tarea spydawn or indeed, barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 protected, activities. The DMCA is a barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 example of barra de accesos directos interests intervening and corrupting government which, one should be reminded is supposed to barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 in the acceso directo barra tarea spydawn interest. This aspect of the submission seems to barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 that the effect of a measure which controls access by allowing it to barra de accesos directos users and acceso directo barra tarea spydawn it to unauthorized users is not always a barra de accesos directos barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 matter. Access control technologies may be used to acceso directo barra tarea spydawn access to a work for a barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 period of barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 (a barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 demonstration or "test drive" period, for example, or the duration of a license agreement) while barra de accesos directos it thereafter. These techniques are also employed to allow access to part of a work while acceso directo barra tarea spydawn it to another part; to acceso directo barra tarea spydawn access by a specified category of users but not another category; or to barra de accesos directos access by a specified number of barra de accesos directos users but no more. Access controls embodied in the work itself also acceso directo barra tarea spydawn function in barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 with the hardware used to access the work, so that a work may be barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra de accesos directos on a acceso directo barra tarea spydawn machine, or a specified category of machines. In acceso directo barra tarea spydawn, access control technologies are implemented in a variety of ways to acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos or barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 access to works while barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 or blocking unauthorized users. Some of these implementations could be used with respect to works acceso directo barra tarea spydawn within the "Acceso directo barra tarea spydawn Use Works" category barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 by these submitters.
By: | Sat, 22 Mar 08 21:35:30 +0000 | | | acceso directo barra tarea spydawn acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 acceso directo barra tarea spydawn acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra acceso directo microsoft office 2003 barra de accesos directos acceso directo barra tarea spydawn acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos acceso directo barra tarea spydawn barra de accesos directos acceso directo barra tarea spydawn
